[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

Buying ETF better than physical gold

The budget changes nothing as far as our investment strategies or themes are concerned. If anything, it reinforces the tried and trusted routes. First let me talk about a couple of supposedly new things that this budget talks about.

A new scheme called Rajiv Gandhi Equity Savings Scheme is proposed. The scheme would allow for income-tax deduction of 50 per cent to new retail investors, who invest up to Rs. 50,000 directly in equities and whose annual income is below Rs. 10 lakh. The scheme will have a lock-in period of three years. We have to wait and see what the “permitted” equities that this scheme will cover. It is very unlikely that this deduction will be allowed for any universal investment. For, if it is so, I will happily buy shares of Infosys or HDFC or HUL or ITC and laugh my way. I can buy every year. So, I think they will limit it to either IPOs or shares in PSUs or some such things. To me, if they let us invest in any share, it is a bonanza. Imagine buying quality shares at a meaningful discount!

The other interesting thing that stands out to me is the clear superiority of buying gold in the ETF form rather than physical. This budget imposes many financial burdens on buying jewellery. The budget proposes a tax collection at source on purchase in cash of bullion or jewellery in excess of Rs. 2 lakh. This looks like it is aimed at curbing black money, but my feel is that people will continue to buy in cash without an invoice. For those of us who would like to invest in gold, physical gold now becomes less attractive and the ETF route becomes a winner again. This has no TDS, no making charges and no excise duty, etc. In fact, one of the fund houses has recently launched a gold ETF, where you can get physical gold in exchange if you have more than 10 gram equivalent in the ETF. Wonder what the authorities are going to do to this mode. Technically, one can beat the TDS route by redeeming for less than Rs. 2 lakh worth in one transaction. In jewellery, it may not be possible to split the bills if a single piece costs more than Rs. 2 lakh.

A small reduction in the Securities Transaction Tax (STT) does not make too much difference to anyone, since the absolute amounts are going to be miniscule. It may help someone who is a compulsive “Buy Today Sell Tomorrow” punter.

The one big negative thing for retail investors is the imposition of TDS on debenture interest when the interest payment exceeds Rs. 5,000 in a year. If one has Rs. 1 lakh in debentures and the annual interest is Rs. 10,000, there will be deduction of tax at source.

The present rate is 10 per cent and maybe this would apply. This will be a big negative for the retail bond investor. Many senior citizens, I know are within the taxable income limit and put substantial money in to bonds because there is no TDS. Now, they will have to live with lower returns. Yes, they will get a refund if they file returns and wait for one to three years. Most senior citizens I know will have a problem filing returns since they will have to find a consultant and spend money on it. I hope the government has a relook at this and like in fixed deposits, let the investor file a form for non-deduction of tax at source, wherever applicable. On the one hand, the government talks about broadening the bond markets and here they create operational problems.

This budget will of course make many things expensive for us. The benefits that we have got are miniscule. Our hope sho-uld be for reduced inflation and lower oil prices. Do not lose much sleep over changing investment strategies or philosophies.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Posted by on Mar 18 2012. Filed under Gold ETFs. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

You must be logged in to post a comment Login